The Original NY Pizza

Reviews

• Alex P.

  star star star star star_border 9 October 2026

  This is my go-to pizza place.  Pizza is about as good as it gets!  Johnnys is their high end pizza competition and I take Original NY pizza any day.  Pizza is really good.
  
  Only downside is their wings.  They are REALLY bad.  Like "I can't believe they are selling these things" bad.  My suggestion would be fry them up and:
  Medium = Franks + butter
  Hot = Franks + a little butter
  BBQ = Sweat Baby Rays
  
  Its pretty much that simple. Whenever we're getting pizza and wings I always get pizza here and wings else ware.

• Kelsey N.

  star star star star star 4 October 2026

  This was my first time trying this even though I've lived in Cary my whole life. My boyfriend just moved to the area and wanted pizza but not "just pizza", he wanted "real pizza." I'd seen this place when I get groceries at Lowe's, and decided it was time to try it.
  Oh, my god, we are never going back to fast food pizza ever again.
  
  We got 3 small things to split. An eggplant parmesan pizza, a stuffed veggie pizza, and their "pasta pot pie." We ate ourselves silly that night. The eggplant parm pizza was definitely the fave a the cheese was rich and not greasy and the crust was so good that even my boyfriend ate them, and he usually doesn't. The stuffed pizza was cheesy with well-cooked veggies and reheated great for my lunch the next day (my coworkers were jealous). The pasta was very different and was rich with ricotta and a meat sauce that was, simply put, a pizza lasagna, but with ziti. And we loved it. Everything about this was wonderful. And their online ordering is super easy and let me choose when to pick up, so the whole experience was a huge win for me. We will DEFINITELY be back soon.

• Wafa I.

  star star star star star_border 29 September 2026

  This is probably the closest thing to NY style pizza that I've gotten since moving here. We ordered a medium cheese pizza and it was obviously the best it can be since it was fresh but honestly felt like something was still missing from true NY pizza.
  
  The service we received was excellent and the guys behind the counter are super nice! I am still on my hunt for the best pizza but for now this is the one I'll be going for when I'm craving a good slice.

• Jay K.

  star star star star star 26 September 2026

  One of the best NY style pizza places left in the Triangle. Their pizza consistently tastes great every (!) single (!) time (!) and their toppings are awesome too. Love the NY posters and wall decor. The only thing missing is an arcade machine.
  
  I really miss the shop that used to be at High House Crossing. They were closer to where I live and they would deliver. I really wish they would come back but the rental greed must be just too much, I guess.

• David S.

  star star star star star_border 25 September 2026

  Decor is nothing special but the pizza is fantastic. I got a few slices of cheese. The crust is thin and crisp and toppings light making it a fantastic combination.
  Prices and service were also welcoming.